
I've been covering the link between future trends and innovation strategies for 30+ years. I went back through my blog posts, stretching to 2002, to dig out the nuggets of innovation insight I've discovered along the way. This series revisits those stories, tests what still holds up, and turns them into practical lessons for what comes next.
"A suggestion box? That's the best way to trivialize the concept of innovation."
One thing I've learned from working with organizations around the world is that culture reveals itself most clearly in what happens immediately after someone raises a new idea. The reaction in that moment tells you far more than the innovation language in the annual report.
Suggestion boxes make innovation look like a side activity. Drop in an idea, hope somebody reads it, return to your real job.
That is the opposite of an innovation culture.
Ideas need conversation, ownership, feedback, resources and decisions. A box creates distance between the person who sees the opportunity and the people who can act on it.
The objective is not to collect more ideas. It is to move useful ideas faster.
This is where culture either reinforces the future or quietly kills it. If you want to change the pattern, start with these three moves.
Action Items:
- Replace passive idea collection with scheduled idea reviews.
- Give every submitted idea a named owner and a response date.
- Measure implementation and learning, not the number of suggestions received.
Explore the full How Innovation Happens series.
Real-World Examples
These researched examples show the lesson at work in the real world.
Morning Star: A tomato processor makes coworkers own the decision
In many organizations, the employee suggestion box has the same hidden instruction: tell management your idea, then return to your job. California tomato processor Morning Star adopted a very different model. It operates with unusual levels of employee self-management, asking workers to negotiate what they will contribute rather than directing every decision up through a conventional hierarchy.
As documented by management researcher Gary Hamel, employees use personal mission statements and Colleague Letters of Understanding to define responsibilities and commitments to one another. People can make operating decisions and acquire tools within their agreed responsibilities. Problems are discussed with colleagues directly instead of being converted automatically into requests for a distant manager to consider.
The model is demanding and not universally transferable. Without clarity and peer accountability, self-management can produce confusion rather than action. Morning Star's approach therefore combines freedom with written commitments, measures and a way to resolve disagreements. The striking feature is that an idea is more likely to arrive with an owner and a conversation than as an anonymous slip of paper.
A useful innovation culture is not defined by how many suggestions it accumulates. It is defined by how quickly the person who notices a problem can work with others to change the process. Morning Star attacks the separation between seeing an opportunity and being authorized to act on it.
Why it matters: Replace anonymous idea collection with explicit ownership, peer dialogue and a path to implementation.
Sources:
LEGO Ideas: A fan proposal travels all the way to the store shelf
Companies say they want ideas from customers. Too often that means a form where a suggestion disappears into an inbox and nobody knows what happened next. LEGO created a more visible mechanism: fans could design proposed sets, explain them publicly, gather community support and, if a proposal reached the required threshold, have it considered in a formal company review.
Science writer Maia Weinstock used LEGO Ideas to propose a Women of NASA set in 2016. Her design celebrated scientists, engineers and astronauts whose contributions had often received too little attention. According to MIT, the proposal collected 10,000 votes in fifteen days, triggering a review by LEGO. The company selected it for production, involving Weinstock in the subsequent design work.
The commercial set was released in November 2017. The final product included four figures rather than every individual in the initial concept, an important reminder that serious innovation processes involve negotiation, licensing, feasibility and decisions. The National Air and Space Museum preserves a prototype, showing how a public proposal can become a tangible manufactured object.
LEGO Ideas is not completely free of central gatekeeping. It is more interesting because the gates are visible and the contributor is part of a defined journey. A suggestion became a public discussion, a reviewable proposition and eventually a product. That is a substantially different experience from dropping an idea into a box and hoping someone notices.
Why it matters: Give ideas transparent milestones, visible feedback and a route into actual decisions and products.
Sources: