
I've been covering the link between future trends and innovation strategies for 30+ years. I went back through my blog posts, stretching to 2002, to dig out the nuggets of innovation insight I've discovered along the way. This series revisits those stories, tests what still holds up, and turns them into practical lessons for what comes next.
One thing I've learned from working with organizations around the world is that culture reveals itself most clearly in what happens immediately after someone raises a new idea. The reaction in that moment tells you far more than the innovation language in the annual report.
Every organization has innovation killers. They are the phrases, people and processes that shut an idea down before it has a chance to breathe.
"We tried that." "Customers won't want it." "Legal will never approve it." "That's not how our industry works."
Sometimes those objections are valid. The problem is when they become automatic.
Naming innovation killers gives you a chance to interrupt the reflex. Once you can hear the phrase, you can ask whether it contains evidence or merely habit.
This is where culture either reinforces the future or quietly kills it. If you want to change the pattern, start with these three moves.
Action Items:
- Collect the ten most common idea-killing phrases in your organization.
- Post them in the meeting room as warnings.
- Require evidence whenever someone uses one to stop an idea.
Explore the full How Innovation Happens series.
Real-World Examples
These researched examples show the lesson at work in the real world.
Procter & Gamble: When “not invented here” became a growth constraint
Procter & Gamble had long relied on its formidable internal research organization to create new consumer products. By the early 2000s, that strength had become a constraint as well. The company could not hire every expert or discover every promising ingredient, package and process on its own, yet the traditional culture tended to favor inventions made inside its walls.
Under CEO A.G. Lafley, the company introduced its Connect + Develop approach, deliberately searching outside the organization for technology, suppliers and entrepreneurs whose work could strengthen P&G products. In a 2006 Harvard Business Review account, company executives explained how the model replaced an exclusive emphasis on invention inside P&G with a structured search for usable ideas wherever they originated.
One documented example involved Pringles Prints, crisps with images and words printed on them. P&G used an external partner's capabilities to accelerate development, describing a shorter process than a purely internal solution would have required. The HBR authors reported that external collaboration had become involved in more than a third of the company's innovations at the time. Those are contemporary management claims, not independent proof of every project outcome.
The innovation killer here was a perfectly respectable phrase: we have our own researchers. Naming the 'not invented here' reflex allowed P&G to challenge it. The organizational change mattered more than any one product. It turned an automatic boundary into a question: who, inside or outside, can help us solve the problem well?
Why it matters: Treat “not invented here” as a hypothesis to test, not as an acceptable reason to reject a better solution.
Sources:
Lockheed Skunk Works: Rules written to stop the organization stopping itself
A wartime aircraft program typically involves elaborate reviews, rigid departmental boundaries and layers of authorization. In the 1940s, Lockheed engineer Kelly Johnson was asked to develop a jet aircraft under extraordinary time pressure. He needed the experience of a major manufacturer without the drag of its normal administrative machinery.
Johnson assembled a small engineering and manufacturing team in separate facilities and built the working arrangements around direct communication and rapid decisions. The organization became known as Skunk Works. Its operating philosophy was eventually expressed in fourteen rules covering team size, authority, reporting, suppliers and the relationship with customers. Lockheed's historical account still emphasizes small, empowered teams and streamlined processes.
Skunk Works went on to develop aircraft including the U-2, SR-71 and F-117, although no single organizational formula explains the technical achievements of different eras. The important point is the design of an exception: a major company acknowledged that its conventional methods were not appropriate for every project, and deliberately established another way to work.
Johnson did not solve bureaucracy by asking employees to be more positive about innovation. He changed who could decide, how few people needed to be involved and what rules governed the work. The visible 'innovation killer' was not a villain. It was an inherited process that had to be redesigned for a new challenge.
Why it matters: Do not merely exhort people to move faster; remove the approval steps that make speed impossible.
Sources: