How Innovation Happens — Lesson #17: Ask the Tough Questions

I've been covering the link between future trends and innovation strategies for 30+ years. I went back through my blog posts, stretching to 2002, to dig out the nuggets of innovation insight I've discovered along the way. This series revisits those stories, tests what still holds up, and turns them into practical lessons for what comes next.


I've come back to this idea repeatedly in my work because the mindset behind innovation usually changes before the results do. What people notice, question, challenge, and act on determines how ready they are for what comes next.

Innovators are not afraid to ask tough questions. More importantly, they are willing to act on the answers.

That second part is where most organizations stumble. They commission research, run off-sites and invite provocative speakers. Then the uncomfortable finding gets softened on the way back into the operating plan.

A tough question is useful only if the answer is allowed to change something.

The questions that matter most are usually the ones people hesitate to ask: What are we pretending not to know? Which product would we kill if we did not already own it? Where are customers tolerating us rather than loving us? Which capability are we losing?

So what does that mean in practice? It means challenging the assumption, habit, or hesitation that is keeping you anchored to the present. Here are three places to start.

Action Items:

  • Ask one question at your next meeting that everyone normally avoids.
  • Assign an owner to investigate the answer.
  • Track whether the answer actually changes a decision.

Explore the full How Innovation Happens series.


Real-World Examples

These researched examples show the lesson at work in the real world.

The surgical checklist: Making it normal for someone to speak up

An operating room has deep expertise, clear hierarchy and enormous pressure to get things right. Those are strengths, but they can also make it difficult to stop a procedure and ask an uncomfortable question about an allergy, an instrument, an antibiotic or the intended operation.

The World Health Organization's Surgical Safety Checklist was designed to turn those questions into an expected part of the workflow, with brief team confirmations before key steps in surgery. Between 2007 and 2008, the checklist was evaluated in eight hospitals across cities including Toronto, Seattle, New Delhi and London.

Researchers reported that major inpatient complications fell from 11 percent to 7 percent and deaths from 1.5 percent to 0.8 percent after implementation. The study was a before-and-after comparison, so those figures are associations in the participating hospitals, not a guarantee of identical results everywhere.

The deeper innovation is behavioural. A simple shared ritual changes the social permission to ask questions and creates a moment when the team must make hidden assumptions explicit. Technical skill remains essential, but a system that cannot hear a concern from a junior person has a vulnerability no amount of expertise at the top can eliminate.

Why it matters: Asking the tough question works best when the organization has built a routine that makes speaking up normal rather than heroic.

Sources:

El Faro: A tragic account of warnings, hierarchy and missing information

On October 1, 2015, the cargo vessel El Faro sank in the Atlantic during Hurricane Joaquin, killing all 33 people aboard. The US National Transportation Safety Board conducted an extensive investigation into the weather information, navigational decisions, company oversight and bridge-resource practices that preceded the loss.

Investigators concluded that the captain did not take sufficient action to avoid the hurricane, relied on noncurrent weather information and ordered the crew to muster too late. The NTSB also identified ineffective bridge resource management among the safety issues.

This is a case where leadership's ability to receive and act upon difficult information had irreversible consequences. It is important not to turn the deaths into a simplistic business parable or imply that one unanswered question alone caused the disaster. Multiple technical and organizational failures contributed.

Yet the record demonstrates why asking whether a plan is wrong matters most when the people in charge are under pressure and the evidence is inconvenient. A system that values confidence more highly than challenge can become dangerously brittle precisely when conditions change. In a high-consequence operation, tough questions are not disloyalty. They are part of the control system.

Why it matters: Leadership must make room for challenge while there is still time to alter a decision. After the crisis, the evidence can only explain what went wrong.

Sources: